Wednesday, 25 September 2013

Maire Geoghegan-Quinn on Seanad abolition – Sunday Times article

It's not that often you get to vote on something that really matters to you, is it?  

I mean, as far as general elections go, you might as well subscribe to international anarchist Emma Goldman's maxim "If voting changed anything they would make it illegal'.

And it's so true.  When it comes to voting my only interest is getting the ones I like least at any given time out of government, though usually it means they simply cross to the other side of the floor for four years and keep their jobs in the meantime.

The great thing about voting to abolish the Seanad (Gaelic for "Senate" - no wonder so many Irish people can't spell properly) would mean that a whole chamber of wasters, shysters, failed TDs and waffling gobshites - with the exception of Bacik perhaps - will be out of a job.  Or one of their jobs, anyway.   

McDowell will have to go back to being a barrister, where the sincerity of ones argument is secondary to its eloquence.  So he should be at home there.  The rest of them will have to devote themselves to their other earners, or coffee mornings and the like.

You hear Irish people complaining about politicians every day.  Let's see what they – a famously conservative constituency – do when they get the chance to actually vote some of them out.

The following article by Brenda Power is well worth a read.

Seanad fat cats should be left to Their Wounds
BRENDA POWER, Sunday Times, 22nd September, 2013

In what parallel universe does Maire Geoghegan-Quinn imagine that her enthusiasm for the Seanad’s retention will have any other effect than to hasten its demise? 

Rarified ast he atmosphere in the VIP section of Dublin airport must be, which Mrs GQ enjoys at a cost to taxpayers of thousands of euros per year, it cannot have removed her from reality to the extent that she believes her support for the upper house will influence voters next month. In fact, one more such endorsement- from, say, that paragon of parliamentary propriety Bertie Ahem-and the electorate won’t
just stop at abolishing the Seanad but may well burn the whole place to the ground. Geoghegan-Quinn revealed she “cut her teeth” as a minister in Seanad debates in the late 1970s, and it taught her everything she knew about politics and legislation. 

Evidently, she believes this will convince an awed populace to race to the polling stations on OCtober 4 to support the Seanad’s existence, berating ourselves for ever having considered voting Yes. The institution that taught an archetypal Fianna Fail grandee, now a featherbedded Eurocrat with a €250,000 salary plus expenses, everything she knows about politics? More of that, please. The chamber that instilled in Geoghegan-Quinn such disdain for the hard-pressed taxpayer that she clung to her €104,000 ministerial and Dail pensions, on top of her EU salary, until it was wre.sted away by dint of shame and public outcry? 

The Seanad that taught her how to bat off queries about enthusiastic use of the airport VIP lounge (in the last six months of 2012 it cost us €5,654 to have GQ pampered between flights to Brussels) by pointing out it was a long-standing privilege for persons of her elevated status- how could we contemplate its abolition? 

There is an argument to be made for a reformed, more democratically elected seanad; Geoghegan-Quinn, however fondly she fancies herself, isn’t it. When the Oireachtas resumed last week, it took two efforts to raise a quorum in the Sean ad because not enough members turned up for the debate. The week before, we learned senator Terry Leyden had made an “honest mistake” when abusing Oireachtas postal privileges to send out €300 worth of invites to a private event. The Seanad could have been reformed years ago had any such impetus come from the people elected to it. But since the senators themselves have shown such cavalier contempt for the chamber which they purport to value, how on earth can they expect the voters to respect it? 

Everything about this unedifying saga - from the taoiseach’s initial journey from reform to abolition while Fianna Fail passed him on the road in the opposite direction, to the cynical posturing of the political debate - embodies those elements of Irish public life the electorate will almost certainly reject on October 4.

Meaningless promises, blatant self-interest, ovenweening arrogance, breathtaking condescension, abundant hot air and vastly inflated expense claims are all dressed up as a vital service to a thankless riffraff. 

Most hilarious of all is that the government’s advertisement campaign is predicated on a gleeful
 reminder that we don’t trust a single one of them. “Fewer politicians!” their posters shriek. 

An even more effective billboard would feature a giant image of Maire Geoghegan -Quinn, a vision of bloated self-irnportance in an executive airline lounge, with the slogan:

“Keep the Seanad – it got me where I am today!”

Back to Gombeen Nation main page


DC3 said...

ff at it again. Doesn't matter one wit as Ireland is not a real countraaay. Transnational lackey. But schhhh if you don't mention it, it doesn't exist.

Ella said...

Hi GM, A politician voting for the retention of the senate is like a turkey voting against christmas.

John said...

Interesting,GM, for a country that has a supposed long historical memory, that this will be the second time that it will abolished.The 1922 Irish Free State Constitution abolished the Senate(which was subordinate to the Dail) in 1936.

Dev revived it in the 1937 Constitution,with less powers that the previous one. Dev liked to use patronage to stay in power and the Senate fitted the bill.

Ella said...

Hi GM, thinking about it maybe we should all vote for keeping the senate, I mean the electorate is of a far superior class than the rest of us, so therefore so should the senators!!

Sandy Beachcomber said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Sandy Beachcomber said...

Good riddance to a useless drain on the country's already depleted finances.
GQ is one I will especially look forward to seeing losing their perks. Now maybe she'll have a chance to see how the rest of the world lives as she has to wait in the departure lounge with the rest of us (and shoulder to shoulder with all those who are emigrating). One hopes that they will take the opportunity to thank her when they see her.

Her title is 'European Commissioner for Research, Innovation and Science' - anyone seen much innovation in Ireland lately?

And the hyphenated name! Only two types of people in Ireland style themselves this way - the landed gentry, and pretentious culchies. Guess which category you fit into, Mary?

Sandy Beachcomber said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Nietzsche Man said...

Yes, McDowell will have to go back to being a barrister and fulfill the promise he made to abstain from public life when he got dumped by the electorate, instead of butting in to public debates on the airwaves. I love the Socialist Party's posters on this one, since they neatly sum up the fact that only about 1% of the population are entitled to vote in Senate - "Make your first vote on the Senate your last. Vote Yes!"

dirtybertie said...

don't be surprised if the ignorant drunken gobshites that comprise the electorate of this godforsaken republic (haha!)get bamboozled once again by the self-serving elite.....lets face it,thats what usually happens.

The Gombeen Man said...

@ DC3. A landing craft for multis.

@ Ella. Yeah, you think they'd try to "dress it up" a bit.

@ John. Dev was the model for them all... the crooked, sneaky Irish politician.

@ Sandy Beachcomber. I honesty think people like M G-Q are so up their own arses they just don't have a clue... not even enough to keep their stupid gobs shut. Like Paddy Flynnstone on the Late Late a few years back. Good to hear from you, BTW. Another sane voice.

@ Nietzsche Man. Why doesn't the fucker keep to his word and leave us alone... Ironically, the PDs - at least early on - were for abolishing the Senate. A change of heart it seems, once ensconced!

@ DirtyBertie. You wouldn't know, would you? We can never underestimate the stupidity of the great Irish public!!!


Jim Spriggs said...

The Gombeen electorate have voted to retain this Gombeen chatting house. What a s**thole this place is! It is being spun as the electorate striking a blow against the Government. I rather think it reflects their stupidity. As for Geoghegan or Quinn or whatever her name is, an FF Gombeen and former teacher being appointed as Commissioner for Research, Science and Innovation for the entirety of Europe simply beggars belief.

The Gombeen Man said...

A madhouae